Blog / Small business / ICHRA
ICHRA for small business in 2027: how it works, who it fits, and when it is the wrong answer
Instead of buying one group plan for everyone, you set a monthly amount and each employee buys their own coverage. It solves problems a group plan cannot, and creates a few of its own. Note that healthcare.gov now calls this a CHOICE Arrangement.
The short answer
An ICHRA lets an employer reimburse employees tax-free for individual health insurance premiums and medical expenses instead of sponsoring a group plan. There is no minimum or maximum contribution, no participation requirement, and employers of any size can offer one. Employees must have their own individual coverage to participate. Healthcare.gov now refers to ICHRAs as CHOICE Arrangements.
- New name: Healthcare.gov now calls ICHRAs CHOICE Arrangements. The rules are the same; only the label changed.
- No contribution cap: Unlike QSEHRA, there is no IRS ceiling on what you can reimburse, and no floor either.
- Any size employer: From one employee upward, provided at least one participant is not a self-employed owner or their spouse.
- 2027 affordability: An ICHRA is affordable if the employee's remaining cost for the lowest-cost self-only silver plan is under 10.22 percent of household income.
Applies to employers considering health coverage for the first time, employers whose group renewal has become unaffordable, and employers with employees spread across multiple states where a single group network does not work.
What is an ICHRA?
An Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangement lets an employer give employees a monthly allowance to buy their own health insurance, reimbursed tax-free, instead of sponsoring a group plan.
The money is not taxable income to the employee and it is deductible to the employer. That is the whole mechanism, and it is why an ICHRA beats simply raising someone’s pay so they can buy coverage: a raise triggers payroll taxes on both sides, a reimbursement does not.
One naming note before anything else. Healthcare.gov now refers to these as CHOICE Arrangements. Same rules, same mechanics, new label. Most brokers, carriers and administrators still say ICHRA, and you will see both for a while.
How is it different from a group plan?
A group plan is one policy covering everyone, with one network, priced on the group as a whole. An ICHRA is a budget. You decide the amount; employees choose the coverage.
| Group plan | ICHRA | |
|---|---|---|
| Who picks the plan | Employer | Each employee |
| Cost to employer | Set by carrier at renewal | Set by you, fixed |
| Participation requirement | Usually 70 percent or more must enroll | None |
| Network | One network for everyone | Whatever each employee buys locally |
| Multi-state employees | Difficult, often a national PPO at a premium | Handled naturally |
| Employee subsidies | Not available | Only if the ICHRA is unaffordable to them |
| Renewal risk | Carrier raises rates on claims experience | You change the allowance or you do not |
The renewal line is the one small employers feel most. With a group plan you find out in the autumn what next year costs. With an ICHRA the number is whatever you decided it would be.
Who does ICHRA actually fit?
Four situations, and if none of them describes you, a group plan is probably still the answer.
- Employees in several states. This is the strongest case. One group network cannot serve someone in Kentucky, someone in Nevada and someone in Florida equally well. Individual coverage in each person’s own market can.
- A group renewal that has stopped making sense. Small groups are rated on their own claims, so one bad year moves the number hard. An ICHRA takes the volatility out.
- Too small for carriers to care. Participation minimums and small-group underwriting shut out a lot of five and six person companies. ICHRA has no participation requirement.
- A workforce that wants different things. A 28-year-old and a 58-year-old rarely want the same plan. One budget, two different choices.
When is ICHRA the wrong answer?
Often enough that anyone recommending it without asking questions is not doing their job.
An older workforce in an expensive rating area. Individual premiums are age-rated per person. A five-person team averaging 55 can cost more through individual coverage than through a small group plan, because group rating spreads age across the pool differently. Run both before deciding.
Lower-wage employees who would qualify for subsidies. If your ICHRA is affordable, they cannot take a premium tax credit. For some employees the subsidy is worth more than your allowance, and offering the ICHRA takes it away. Employers under 50 full-time equivalents can deliberately design a modest allowance so subsidies stay available, which is legal and sometimes the kindest option.
Thin individual markets. In some counties the individual market has narrower networks and fewer carriers than the group market. If your employees’ doctors are not in any available individual plan, the flexibility is theoretical.
Employees who will not enroll. An ICHRA only works if people actually buy coverage. Someone has to walk each employee through their own state’s marketplace. If nobody owns that step, the benefit fails quietly.
What does affordability mean, and why does it matter?
An ICHRA is considered affordable when what the employee still has to pay for the lowest-cost self-only silver plan in their area, after your allowance, is less than a set percentage of their household income. For 2027 that percentage is 10.22 percent, up from 9.96 percent in 2026.
Two consequences follow.
If you have 50 or more full-time equivalent employees, you are an applicable large employer, and an unaffordable ICHRA can expose you to a shared-responsibility penalty. Because you cannot know anyone’s household income, the IRS provides safe harbors based on federal poverty level, rate of pay, or W-2 wages. Use one and document it.
If you have fewer than 50, the penalty does not apply, which gives you room to design the allowance around what actually helps your people rather than around a compliance threshold.
How does it work in practice?
Setting one up
- Decide the classes. Full-time, part-time, seasonal, salaried versus hourly, and employees in different rating areas can all receive different allowances.
- Set the monthly allowance per class. You can vary it by age and by family size within a class, within limits.
- Give notice. Employees generally need at least 90 days’ notice before the plan year, less for a new plan or a new hire.
- Employees buy individual coverage. Offering an ICHRA triggers a special enrollment period, so they are not stuck waiting for open enrollment.
- Employees substantiate coverage, then submit expenses. An administration platform handles this. Doing it on your own is possible and rarely worth it.
- You reimburse, tax-free, up to the allowance. Unused allowance stays with you.
The step employers underestimate is the fourth one. Each employee has to actually enroll, in their own state’s market, and some of them will not do it without help. Budget for someone to walk them through it.
ICHRA or QSEHRA?
QSEHRA is the older, smaller cousin. It is limited to employers with fewer than 50 full-time equivalents and it has annual IRS contribution caps. ICHRA has no cap and no size limit, and it allows class-based design that QSEHRA does not.
QSEHRA still wins in one situation: employees can keep their premium tax credits, reduced by the QSEHRA amount, rather than losing them entirely. For a lower-wage workforce that can matter more than the flexibility.
We covered the broader HRA landscape in health reimbursement options for small employers and the account types in HSA versus HRA for small business.
So which should you do?
Quote both. That is the only honest answer, and it is not a dodge.
The variables that decide it are your employee ages, the counties they live in, what they earn, and whether your team is in one state or five. Nobody can tell you from the outside which wins, and anyone who says ICHRA is always better is selling administration software.
What we do is model both with your actual census and show you the annual cost side by side, including what employees would pay out of their own pockets under each. Start at our small business page, or see how the traditional route works in small business health insurance.
Questions people ask
Do employees have to buy from the marketplace?
No. Individual coverage bought directly from a carrier off-exchange also qualifies, as does Medicare Part A with Part B, or Medicare Advantage. What does not qualify is short-term medical, a health care sharing ministry, fixed indemnity, or a spouse's group plan.
Can an employee take a premium tax credit instead?
Only if the ICHRA is unaffordable for them. If it is affordable, they must either use the ICHRA or waive it and buy unsubsidized. That trade matters most for lower-wage employees, and matters little when the allowance is generous.
Is there a minimum I have to contribute?
No. There is no floor and no ceiling. Some small employers deliberately design a modest allowance so that lower-paid employees can claim subsidies instead, which is legal for employers under 50 full-time equivalents.
Can I offer ICHRA to some employees and a group plan to others?
Yes, by class. Full-time, part-time, seasonal, salaried versus hourly, and employees in different rating areas can be treated differently. What you cannot do is offer the same employee both a group plan and an ICHRA.
What happens at open enrollment?
Offering an ICHRA triggers a special enrollment period, so employees can buy individual coverage outside the usual window. They have to actually enroll, which is the part most employers underestimate.
Is ICHRA cheaper than a group plan?
Sometimes. It is predictable, which is different. You set the cost rather than receiving a renewal. Whether the total is lower depends on employee ages and where they live, because individual premiums are age-rated per person.
Sources
- HealthCare.gov, CHOICE Arrangements (formerly ICHRA), accessed September 18, 2026
- CMS, Individual Coverage Health Reimbursement Arrangements policy overview, August 28, 2020
- IRS, 2027 health plan affordability threshold, 2026
Want to see ICHRA and a group plan side by side?
Send your employee count, their ages, and the states they work in. We will model both approaches with real numbers so you can see which one actually costs less for your team. One business day, no cost.
Compare my optionsCall or text (773) 657-9140Smart Insurance Agents LLC is an independent, licensed insurance agency and is not connected with or endorsed by the U.S. government or the federal Medicare program. We do not offer every plan available in your area. Please contact Medicare.gov, 1-800-MEDICARE, or your local State Health Insurance Assistance Program for information on all of your options. Content is for general information and is not a guarantee of coverage or rates; figures are subject to change by CMS and carriers.